It happens a lot: someone receives Murdoku 3 as a gift, or spots the blue cover and gets curious, and only afterwards notices the "Volume 3". The question is natural. Will it make sense without the first two?
The answer is yes, and it is not just an opinion: the series' original publisher states that each book is designed so that a beginner can start with it.
Why it works
The Murdoku books have no characters running through the series and no story that continues from one volume to the next. Each case is a self-contained page: a scene, a list of suspects, a set of clues and a culprit. And each book opens with instructions and a worked example.
The rules in ten minutes
Before the first case, you only need four ideas:
- The scene is divided into squares, like a sudoku grid, and into rooms, like a floor plan.
- Each suspect takes one square, and there are never two people in the same row or column.
- Each suspect's clues refer to what is in the illustration: an object, a room, an animal.
- Once all the suspects are placed, the victim is in the only square left, and the culprit is whoever was alone with them in the same room.
The example at the start of the book shows these rules in action. For a longer explanation, the article How to play Murdoku covers the full method and the most common mistakes.
What you lose by skipping volumes
Not much. Starting with book 3 means missing 160 cases of practice, which you notice mostly at the end of the book, where the twists described in secret identities and multiple grids appear. In those cases, an experienced solver has an edge. But the first half of the book does the same teaching job, and the difficulty curve was designed for exactly that.
You also miss the surprise of seeing the series move from everyday settings to historical eras and then to a world tour. A small pleasure, and one you can recover later.
What you gain
- The most varied settings in the series, from Paris to Antarctica.
- The newest book, with the most polished rules.
- The freedom to go back to volumes 1 and 2 later with a sharper method, and solve them faster.
And after volume 3?
If you start with the third and enjoy it, two more books are waiting: volume 1 and volume 2, Regresso ao Passado, also available together in the two-book bundle (all Portuguese editions). The article on the order to solve the Murdoku books will help you plan the rest of the journey.
